Dear Friends,
Now, more than ever, we need to recognize that there is arguably no better “classroom environment” than participation in sports for teaching and learning social and emotional skills.
Bad temper. Zero empathy for others. Lousy teammate. Constantly breaks team rules. Thinks they can do wrong. No one objectively would want a player like this on their team. And yet I still come across way too many coaches and programs who don’t value social emotional learning and/or tolerate parents whose behaviors mirror those of the traits of the child described above.
I spend a lot of time tying my work as a counselor to the work I do in the Physical Literacy development space. I think we can all agree that we’ve moved well past Social Emotional Learning (SEL) from being just a buzz term to something we see being fully integrated into our schools and programs. But, like a lot of initiatives, some schools/programs are better at implementation than others.
The Collaborative for Academic, Social, and Emotional Learning (CASEL) suggests there are 5 core competencies that we should focus on. They are:
Self Management
Self Awareness
Social Awareness
Responsible Decision Making
Relationship Skills
One of the many reasons I am so saddened by the extraordinary decline in youth sport participation is that I strongly believe there is literally no better place for children to develop these skills than in a sport setting. And let’s be clear – these are skills! And like any skill, you need the opportunity to “try things out”, get feedback and then try again. Yes – in the same way we encourage kids to sample sports to discover where they might be best suited, children need the opportunity to try out self regulation skills and learn through trial and error when learning responsible decisions and building relationships.
Let’s break each of the CASEL core competencies down in a youth sport context as way of discussion.
Self Awareness – part of the growing up process is identifying our own personal strengths and weaknesses. And, sadly, in today’s social media saturated world, children and adolescents are unfortunately more keenly aware of perceived personal shortcomings than they are in recognizing (and owning) their strengths. Giving a child the opportunity to try out a variety of sports, free from pressure allows them to not only discover how their own physical make-up impacts what they might enjoy and be good at, but also how their personality traits impact how they navigate the world. Skills developed: Identifying emotions, Self confidence, Ability to recognize strengths and weaknesses.
Self Management – Ask any adolescent how they’re feeling, and a likely answer you will get is “STRESSED!!” The beauty of sport is that it safely simulates stress on a regular basis, putting kids in situations where they need to work collaboratively, work hard and often under a time constraint (the clock is running in many sports – or you’re trying to do things faster than an opponent). It also mimics the symptoms of anxiety. When we get anxious, our heart races, we get short of breath and we sweat. That happens a lot in sport as well. If we can teach kids to self-regulate when exercise induced play brings on the symptoms, then they can better handle the symptoms when life’s inevitable anxiety and stress bring them on. Skills developed: Impulse control, Stress management, Self-discipline, Self-motivation, Goal-setting, Organizational skills
Social Awareness – One of our most basic needs is the one to belong. Being part of a sports team fulfills that need and immediately puts children in a safe place to navigate the challenges of being part of social groups that happen when everyone on your team is working towards a common goal. It often forces children to work with others who don’t think like them or look like them, but because of the shared experience develops bonds that are hard to reproduce in other youth settings. Skills developed: Perspective-taking, Empathy, Appreciating diversity, Respect for others
Relationship Skills – It’s one thing to be aware of others and to be conscious of where/how you fit into that social construct, it’s another thing to effectively interact and build trust and friendship with others. The added bonus of doing this as part of a sports team is that children get to work on relationships with multiple other children in their age group, but hopefully get to develop relationship skills with a caring adult (their coach) as well. It moves children from a self-centered construct to one of helping others reach their goals as well. Skills developed: Communication, Social engagement, Relationship-building, Teamwork
Responsible Decision Making – I am a huge believer that we do our best learning through failure. I will argue here again, that under the right coach and right conditions, being on a team and involved in sports allows children the benefits of making good choices, and learning the potential detriment of making poor choices. There is the great expression that “Integrity is what you do when no one else is watching”, but as kids navigate right from wrong, there is no better setting to try out right from wrong than under the tutelage of a caring coach and with others who are learning these lessons right alongside you. Skills developed: Identifying problems, Analyzing situations, Solving problems, Evaluating, Reflecting, Ethical responsibility
If your child (or teen for that matter) is part of a program where you feel the coaches and/or administrators don’t really care about any of the above, I would ask you to assess what it is you really want your kids to get out of sports. If it is only to develop those physical traits that you think will make them attractive to college coaches, then I will ask you this – Do you think that a college coach really wants a player who is not self aware, who is socially clueless, cant get along with teammates, can’t control their emotions and constantly makes poor choices? Sure – there sadly might be a few out there who are selfish enough and share those traits themselves that might say yes – but is that really what you’re looking for.
I apologize that this piece may have been a bit more “heady” than my typical ones, but I think the reason I’ve always been so drawn to sports is because of the core social emotional competencies inherit in them. It’s why I believe that if schools are really serious about developing Social and Emotional Learning Skills then every child should have the opportunity to regularly participate in sports – at least through middle school, Developing healthy children – both physically and emotionally – depends on it!
About Steve Boyle
Steve is the Executive Director of 2-4-1 CARE, Inc and Co-Founder/Director of 2-4-1 Sports -- a signature program of 2-4-1 CARE-- whose flagship program is held at the Kingswood Oxford School in West Hartford, Conn. but now has locations throughout the United States and Canada. 2-4-1 was recognized by the Aspen Institute in Washington, DC as one of eight model programs in the United States for its approach to anti-specialization in youth sports. This led Steve to form the National Association of Physical Literacy – of which he is now Advisory Board Chair. Steve is also a founding member of the Quality Coaching Collective – an international group of activators around sport, movement and mindfulness. Lastly, through his role at CCG, Steve was the two-year Global Lead on Physical Literacy and Athletics for Whittle School & Studios (2018-20), which currently has campuses in Shenzhen, China and Washington, DC.